From Shastra to Astra: The Weapon That Chooses Its Target
I start every morning with the BBC and The Economist podcasts. Twenty-five minutes each, the world through a North Atlantic lens. Usually it’s coffee-and-headlines stuff.
Today one story stopped me cold.
Autonomous weapons systems (AWS) are machines built to hunt programmable targets. Make them small enough and you can program them to target a group or segment of people. Not a battalion. Not a building. A category of humans.
A few years ago that was sci-fi. Today it’s a podcast segment between the weather and the markets.

The Argument I Spent Years Building
My formative years went into one question: how do governments reduce death by lethal weapons?
My answer: arms and ammunition should be state-owned and state-monitored. Keep the profit motive away from the business of killing.
Three models have been tried:
GOGO: government-owned, government-operated
GOCO: government-owned, contractor-operated
COCO: contractor-owned, contractor-operated
The data seemed to settle it. The US, closest to COCO, records far higher deaths from lethal weapons than Europe or India, which lean GOGO or GOCO. Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs, and Steel backed my instincts on how technology shapes power.
I had the data, the book and the logic. Then AWS arrived.
Our Own Itihasa Saw This Coming
Bharatiya itihasa draws a sharp line between two classes of weapons.
Shastra (very generically not perfect description) is the weapon in the hand: sword, mace, spear. The wielder is present, in range, at risk. Every blow is a human decision carried out by a human body.
Astra is the weapon released. Invoked by mantra, loosed from a distance, it flies to a target and does what it was invoked to do. Agneyastra, Varunastra, Pashupatastra, Brahmastra. Each was bound to a purpose and a deity.
Read that again with 2026 eyes. The mantra was the programme. The invocation set the target, the conditions and the effect. The warrior stepped back and the weapon did the rest.
We are migrating from shastra to astra. Not metaphorically. Literally.
What the Mahabharata Knew
The epics treated astras as civilisation-ending power, and they wrapped them in rules.
Using a Brahmastra against ordinary foot soldiers was adharma. Astras were meant for equals, not the helpless. Even in war, the target was a moral question.
Then comes the warning that matters most. After the war, Ashwatthama, in rage, launched the Brahmashira. Arjuna, bound by duty, countered. Cosmic catastrophe loomed until the sages intervened. Arjuna withdrew his astra, because he had been taught the knowledge of recall. Ashwatthama had not. He knew how to launch but not how to stop. The weapon had to go somewhere, and it went to the wombs of the unborn.
That is the oldest argument for AI governance ever written. Launching without the ability to recall is not power. It is irresponsibility with a delivery mechanism.
Why My Old Framework Breaks
My entire model assumed weapons are objects that need to be owned. Ownership means licences, audits, serial numbers, checkpoints. Regulate the factory, count the bullets.
But who “owns” software? Who audits an algorithm? Who tracks a swarm of insect-sized devices built from commercial components and steered by code that copies in a second?
GOGO versus COCO now feels like debating carriage regulations in the age of the jet engine. Ownership still matters. Its consequences are now limited.
Technology Democratises. Including Killing.
We love saying technology democratises opportunity. It put a bank in every pocket and a classroom on every phone.
But democratisation is morally neutral. It democratises capability, and capability includes the capability to kill.
Old weapons were blunt and killed whoever stood in the way. The astra of the algorithm is selective, and selective means discriminatory in the darkest sense. A weapon that can be told whom to kill can be told to kill by identity. That isn’t warfare. That’s engineered persecution with a software update.
America’s Fear Is Not Stupid
America’s “guns for all” rests on a real historical fear: the state can become the predator. Add precision targeting in the state’s hands and that fear sharpens.
But look at functioning democracies. It is rare to see the state systematically turn violence on its own subjects. There, safety comes from institutions, not inventory: courts that bite, a free press, accountable parliaments.
Answer fear of the state with private, for-profit enterprise and you get a business model built on insecurity. The more afraid people are, the more they buy, and the more profit flows to those who sell fear. That road ends in anarchy and chaos.
Now put astras on that shelf. If private players can sell programmable lethality to anyone who can pay, the question is no longer “should citizens be armed?” It is “who writes the mantra, and whom does it hunt?”
What We Must Do
I don’t have a neat answer. Anyone who claims one is selling something. But the direction is clear:
Treat this as a governance story, not a defence story. It belongs in boardrooms, parliaments and classrooms.
Regulate capabilities, not just objects. You can’t license every line of code. You can draw bright red lines. Targeting humans by group identity must be one, agreed internationally and enforced.
Build institutions, not arsenals. Courts, press, transparency and citizens who show up are the real defence.
Keep accountability human. A machine can’t be tried, jailed or shamed. Whoever launches must be answerable, and must hold the knowledge of recall. Arjuna’s discipline should be the standard. Ashwatthama’s should be the crime.
The Question I Can’t Shake
My younger self thought the hardest problem was who owns the weapon.
Today I think it’s who decides the target.
Our ancestors understood that the moment you release a weapon from the hand, ethics must travel with it. The shastra age let us hide behind the wielder. The astra age gives us nowhere to hide.
I began this morning with coffee and a podcast, and ended it questioning a belief I’d held for decades. Uncomfortable, yes. It’s also how thinking is supposed to feel.
Your Turn
This conversation can’t stay inside defence ministries and think tanks. Can regulation keep pace with technology this fast? Where should the red lines be drawn? Share your view in the comments, send this to someone who’ll disagree with me, and let’s build a community that holds the line before it’s crossed.




Comments